More Pages: Todd Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99


Mediocre
reply to dewdrops
An okay first entry into (hopefully) a long-lived seriesThe research does not, however, stack up to the corresponding analysis in Baseball Prospectus. Of course this is an unfair comparison for a couple of reasons: baseball research has been going on for far longer, and BP has been publishing for seven years now and has gotten a lot of framework in place for studying the game; and even more fundamentally, football is a much harder game to analyze. Each play in baseball involves primarily the batter and the pitcher and usually one fielder; it is relatively easy to assign credit or blame on each play. (Rating fielders is difficult, but play-by-play data and new techniques are helping to improve fielding metrics.) Each play in football is affected by the majority of the 22 players on the field -- even, say, wide receivers on a running play are throwing blocks or acting as decoys to stretch the defense. As a result, the authors' rankings of each team's offensive line, front seven, and defensive backfield seem pretty dicey when just calculated from raw stats. For instance, they rank offensive lines just by looking at the allowed-sacks-per-pass-attempt rate and the team's yards-per-rush, which is a good start but leaves out the QB's mobility, the RBs' quality, and about 50 other things that affect these stats. Analysis of these nearly stat-less units is long overdue and much appreciated, but there is so much noise in the numbers (from different styles of play, strength of schedule, interaction with other units, etc.) that you have to take these relatively simple rankings with a large grain of salt.
On the other hand, if I recall correctly the authors said that over the off-season they reviewed every play from every game from last year. Between compiling their own play-by-play data and initiating a statistical framework in which to build on, they've got the potential in future books to break new ground. Admittedly though, I don't remember reading anything exciting in PFP 2002. (I might also be biased against the book because they panned my team, the Browns. Certainly many fans were way too optimistic before the season started, but I think PFP's 6-10 prediction went too far the other way.)


Agree with barjones, terrible presentation
The best book on this topic
Great book for web-based ADSI and CDO issues

Light-hearted reading with an edge
As a Young Justice fan I was disappointed.The concept is lighthearted and fun, but combining the stories from various titles meant that while some writing was good, a lot of the writing was rather weak. Overall the different writing and artistic styles made the book feel choppy, and not as though the stories belonged together. I don't regret buying it, but I was disappointed.
Try A League of Their Own (Young Justice) by Peter David and D. Curtis Johnson for a good Young Justice book.
Without Arrowette, it's a little disappointing

This book fails to deliver detailed information.
Visual Basic 5 SuperBible with CDROM
The Best Reference Guide Yet!!

WORTHLESS
price is disproportionate to valueI received this book today, but will return it tomorrow.
Interesting and well written

Total Pile
It's an additional resource; not "the Bible"It IS your Red Rocks' "Bible" if you are a sport climber.
Need Improvement

Easily the Worst book I can remember buyingI am sorry I wasted my money & was responsible for the deaths of the trees that made it!
Mac OS X Java
Just what I was looking for...

Could be better.
Clear, illuminating
sweet, simple, solid

Self-serving drivel
wrong and silly
Disappointed

Out-of-date
Untrustworthy source of information for beginnersChapter 7 - Working with Novell Netware
"NetWare does not provide DNS or DHCP services. These network services, if required on the network, must be provided by a server running some other NOS."
This guy knows nothing about Netware - since 1998 Netware has built-in DNS and DHCP servers.
If you want a real good begginners guide go to : Computer Networking: A Top-Down Approach Featuring the Internet by James Kurose and Keith Ross (ISBN 0-201-47711-4)
Its really an excellent source of information for beginners
Pretty Easy to FollowI notice a few complaints about the age of the book, but I purchased the 3rd addition and it was first printed in June 2001, so I don't see what the gripes are for; it's current.